Jessica Levold’s Weblog

Judgments from Jessica…

Whose thought is it anyways?

If we were to take an individual and ask them for their predictions on the upcoming presidential election would their opinion be the same as if we took that same individual, stuck him/her in a room full of people with opposing opinions for an hour and then once again asked that individual who they believe the next president is going to be? Maybe not, but probably. Behold the power of group think.

We have all been involved in group think at one point in our lives. Whether we have stayed true to our original ideas and thoughts or followed the masses, we all at some point have been subjected to what happens when a whole bunch of people come together with a whole bunch of different ideas.

So the real question here is, is group think good or bad? Can it overturn the majority’s opinion? Quite possibly. For example, if we as a country think that our healthcare system is unjust, what would happen if we all rallied together and refused to settle until the issue was resolved. Of course we would have to tear down the government, which is no simple feat, until they too realized, “Hey something needs to be done about the healthcare system in our nation.” Although, the government ultimately has the final say, we are a society have the power to force them to get to that point where they are forced to make that decision.

So, when really analyzing how a decision came to be, does it really matter whose thought it is anyways as long as the right one is ultimately made when it comes to benefitting the majority?

 

- In what ways does group think exist in the world of journalism? Do journalists “group think” when it comes to deciding on what stories to report to the media?

- In what ways does group think influence your decisions in your personal life? political beliefs?

May 4, 2008 - Posted by jlevold | reading | | 1 Comment

1 Comment »

  1. Great response! I definitley agree with you that groupthink can be a great thing in certain situations, as well as a horrible thing. For example, groupthink could be great when rallying together to make voices heard. It can be a bad thing when we stop thinking as individual people. I wish that our society took greater action towards the government. There are so many issues we disagree upon as a society and I wish people no longer feared the power of “taking it to the streets.”We have the power, and groupthink can help us to that position of demanding the greater good of the governement.

    In response to your question - does it really matter who’s idea it was as long as the best decision is there in the end? I don’t think it does matter, as long as the good of the whole is reached. It may matter in a sense, but only to credit the person that was the creative genius…

    Comment by noltes2 | May 11, 2008

Leave a comment